About This Spot

Stepping into Andrea's West Yarmouth Fish and Lobster feels like entering a cherished local treasure where the rhythm of the Cape Cod coast quietly hums through every corner. The space buzzes with a welcoming energy that’s both purposeful and relaxed—shoppers mingle thoughtfully, sharing tips or simply savoring the anticipation that comes with selecting the freshest catch of the day. It’s the kind of place where the air carries a briny tang mixed with the comforting hum of community being nurtured.

Behind the counters, the day’s bounty is displayed with an unpretentious pride. This is not a place of fuss or flash; rather, it’s grounded in tradition and trust, where freshness speaks louder than any menu. Whether picking up fillets for a spontaneous grill or gathering ingredients for a special meal, arriving here feels like joining a quiet conversation with the sea itself.

Locals and visitors alike find something deeply satisfying in the ritual of shopping at Andrea’s: the careful choice of fish glistening with promise, the sight of lobster meat piled just right for a light, effortless dinner, or the joy of assembling a seafood boil that fills the kitchen with warmth and laughter. It’s less about hurried service and more about moments—selecting a sweet salmon, catching the last shrimp of the day, or simply unpacking those iconic lobster rolls that feel like a small celebration in every bite.

The pace here invites you to slow down, listen to familiar greetings, and soak in the genuine care woven into every transaction. It’s a place where freshness isn’t just a promise—it’s a shared experience between those who harvest from the sea and those who bring those flavors to life in their homes. Andrea’s quietly embodies the charm of Cape Cod’s seafood heritage, offering not just ingredients, but connections to a place and its people.

What’s Available Here

  • IconIdentifies as women-owned
  • IconSmall Business
  • IconCredit cards
  • IconDebit cards
  • IconSNAP/EBT
  • IconCredit cards

Location & Hours

Guest Reviews

Todd Bray 27 Dec 2025

When anywhere near South Yarmouth on Cape Cod we shop for the freshest seafood at Andrea’s . The Faro Island Salmon is consistently the sweetest best Salmon I can get anywhere. Fresh Cod is always a must. For the special occasions we buy the sweet lobster meat and make Lobster Rolls for our visiting guest. The perfect light dinner on a hot summer evening is shrimp cocktail and home made Guacamole . Never disappointed with the seafood and super helpful staff. We usually stop twice a week. See you there!

Gene Fischer 27 Dec 2025

First time doing a seafood boil. All the seafood came fresh from Andrea's and it was delicious. 3 lb lobster, halibut, swordfish on the side. Which was absolutely amazing. In the boil was clams, shrimp and other veggies. So tasty. Great seafood, very good prices, amazing meal. Thank you Andreas and highly recommend.

Alex Issokson (Boston Foodie) 19 Dec 2025

Amazing selection of fresh fish here! I always come here when I’m down the Cape to buy fish and I’m never disappointed. Whether it’s sole, tuna, or anything else, you can’t go wrong. It always looks so great in store and often times the hard part is figuring out what to get. Great location too!

Mike McCarthy 07 Dec 2025

I hesitate to let this secret out but the $20 lobster roll here is just as good as those places that charge $35 to $40! This is I am sure not frozen lobster that you might find elsewhere. We have had them three times (8 rolls) and excellent each time. Even bought the night before to take out on the boat lunch while fishing!

Nicole Digenis 24 Nov 2025

Local & always fresh fish. Go earlier in day before popular items run out. They also sell cooked lobsters, lobster rolls, and “clambake” boxes, ready to take home and eat. We always get our fish to grill here!

Sheila Furrer 23 Nov 2025

By far THE best place to purchase seafood in the Mid-Cape area. Seafood is fresher than fresh. Service reminds me of the "old" days when customer service was the number one priority. I was raised in Chatham and was taught that if you could smell fish, turn around and leave. I have never had that problem with West Yarmouth Fish and Lobster. Their little shanty is impeccably clean. If you haven't ever been, and you enjoy seafood, you really should stop in!

Moon Frank Mary 04 Nov 2025

Fresh and delicious seafood. Great lobster roll! We also had cooked jumbo shrimp and the spicy stuffed quahogs. Everything is to go, no tables. The reviews are a little confusing so I wasn't sure.

Rachel Treide 21 Oct 2025

Picturesque spot for fresh, delicious seafood. The oysters from Wellfleet were super tasty, fresh, and very reasonably priced. My dad’s first raw oyster in 40 years!! Such a treat. The clams were excellent and the tuna was a gorgeous, deep red. Made wonderful spaghetti alle vongole and tuna crudo. Prices and great and service is helpful. This will be my go-to for fresh seafood on the Cape from now on

Share Your Experience
Related Listing

Recently Viewed Listing

4.3
695 Reviews

Amazing Burger

3780 Old Norcross Rd #302, Duluth, GA 30096, United States
4.4
227 Reviews

Titanic Kitchen & Lounge

469 High Rd Leytonstone, London E11 4JU, United Kingdom
4.3
473 Reviews

King Chop Suey

6224 W Florissant Ave, St. Louis, MO 63136, United States
4.2
372 Reviews

Mat & Harmoni Gastelyckan

Fältspatvägen 4, 224 78 Lund, Sweden
4.3
1878 Reviews

Restaurant Plat Rodó

Avinguda de Catalunya, 49, 17520 Puigcerdà, Girona, Spain
Subscribr Now

Get All Updates & Advance Offers